Finale Blog: If It Ain’t Broke…

by Tom Johnson 10. May 2011 07:09
 



Being a practical guy, I generally agree with the philosophy of “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” However, I make exceptions. My old typewriter still works fine, yet I’ve found that my laptop provides me with a more efficient means to communicate my thoughts.

In creating new versions of Finale, we always strive to improve the user experience while being sensitive to the fact that not everyone wants a new experience; when providing new ways to do things we typically make it possible for you to still do it the old way, too. As a result, sometimes long-time Finale users continue to do things the way they always have – long after a better option exists. (And of course the question of what is “better” is very subjective.)

Often when I’m speaking with Finale users, someone will refer to part extraction without mentioning Linked Parts, and I’ll discover that they don’t know Linked Parts exist. Linked Parts is the Finale feature that automatically creates parts for your score, and ensures that edits made in your parts instantly appear in your score – and vice versa. Prior to Linked Parts, you would extract parts, creating many separate Finale files based on the way the score looked at that instant. Then you had to manage a whole bunch of separate part files, and hopefully you took the time to update the score whenever you changed notes in the part.

For me, the way Linked Parts transformed this process was no less dramatic than what word processing software did to my writing. Best of all, there’s nothing to turn on, I simply create new scores from Finale’s Setup Wizard and my parts are automatically generated.

However, if you’ve in the habit of starting new files from an old template, parts will not be automatically generated. If this describes you, or if you are simply working in an old file created before Linked Parts, the good news is that it’s simple to add parts after the fact too!

To see the Linked Parts in your score, go to Document > Edit Part:

If parts exist in your score, you’ll see them listed here. Just click on the part name, like “Cello,” to see individual parts, and note the handy keystrokes for moving between your parts (Next Part, etc.).

If parts don’t currently exist in your score, simply click on Generate Parts:

…and new parts will appear the next time you select Document > Edit Part.

Have any questions about using Linked Parts? Please let us know by clicking on “Comments” below! 
 

Tags: , , , ,

Customer Support Tips | Tom Johnson

Comments

5/7/2011 12:32:22 PM #

Jeremy Levy

Linked parts are incredibly useful, but they could still be much more powerful if it was easier to change certain elements between score and parts.  For instance:

1. Time signatures - You cannot have them turned off in the score, but on in the part (i.e. engraver time sigs for score)
2. Display whole rests in empty bars.  I like having whole rests turned off in the score for a clean look, but obviously they need to be on in parts
3. Font sizes for expressions and text blocks.  Fixed text sizes are not always optimal.

I am aware that staff styles can take care of most of these issues, but it is not the most elegant solution.

Jeremy Levy United States

5/7/2011 2:05:14 PM #

Scott Yoho

Hi Jeremy,

Thanks for the excellent feedback on where you'd like to see Linked Parts improved in the future. Anyone unclear how to use staff styles to accomplish these tasks today? Would that be a helpful blog post?

Scott at MakeMusic

Scott Yoho United States

5/8/2011 12:01:27 PM #

Brian Megilligan

I think this is a great feature and once I figured out how to use it, I appreciated the flexibility it gave me--especially when editing part layout and noticing a missing slur, or dynamic marking, or something like that and once edited in the part is immediate reflected back in the score.

I don't know if this has been addressed in the latest version, but one of my biggest frustrations with this feature was that it worked against you if you were trying to do step by step arrangements or if you had to come back and add another series of parts. For example, I could start an arrangement and do the rhythm and vocal parts, generate and edit the parts through this tool, print them and distribute them, then come back later and add horn parts. The problem is, simply adding horn parts to the score does not mean they will show up in the part list. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, you have to "generate" parts all over again which for some reason destroys the previous work you've done on the other parts (i.e., your formatting and layout edits are lost).

Also, in my opinion, the "manage parts" menu does not handle staff grouping very intuitively. I'm confused about the naming convention. Apparently you can't name a group of staves as well as assign individual staff names within the group. It gets all confused.

Again, maybe I need help on understanding how it's supposed to work, but I've had mixed love-it/hate-it feelings about this feature as with others across this software.

Brian Megilligan United States

5/10/2011 1:02:24 AM #

Jeremy Levy

Brian,

You don't have to regenerate parts from scratch when adding new staves to your score.  If the new staves didn't show up in the manage parts dialog (there is a check box for this in the create new staves wizard), then you can click create new part and then add the stave(s) from the menu on the far right.

As for the confusion about staff groups, agreed.  It is definitely a little confusing.

Jeremy Levy United States

5/11/2011 10:16:25 AM #

Bob Freedman

I realize that there are many Finale users who are enamored with the linked parts feature. I am not one of them. It gets in my way. But neither am I interested in arguing against that innovation. But I do wish that it were an option that could be utilized or not at the discretion of the user. I am forced to upgrade every year because I have clients who do so and I need to be able to read, and sometimes work with, their Finale files. Otherwise I'd still be using v.2006, which gives me reasonable ability to do things the way I want to do them.

It would be great if Finale's next big breakthrough were something like "It's Your Choice".

Bob Freedman United States

5/14/2011 3:46:28 PM #

Scott Yoho

Hi Brian,

When you need to add staves to your score after-the-fact, do so by selecting New Staves (with Setup Wizard) from the Staff menu. Staves added in this manner WILL appear in the parts list (plus it’s a quicker way to assign the correct transposition and name).

I agree that it’d be nice if you could rename and bracket staves in Manage Parts. Today that’s still best done with the Staff Tool, but I’m glad to forward your suggestion. Thanks for the feedback!

Scott at MakeMusic

Scott Yoho United States

5/14/2011 3:50:03 PM #

Scott Yoho

Hi Bob,

Thanks for your feedback.

If you had the time, I'd be interested to learn how linked parts gets in your way. To my way of thinking, if I never went to Document > Edit Part, I'd never know that Linked Parts were there.

Is the problem that your clients have used Linked Parts in thier documents, and you'd rather not?

Scott at MakeMusic

Scott Yoho United States

Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.5.0.7
Theme by Mads Kristensen

Welcome!

This blog was created to provide an interactive means to share commentary and tips on the Finale family of music notation products.

RecentComments

Comment RSS